* Detail Valuation Methods
Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) Model
The DCF model is considered the foundation of valuation, based on the principle that a company’s value is the sum of all its future cash flows discounted to present value.
Key Formula:
“`
Company Value = Σ (FCF_t / (1 + r)^t) + Terminal Value
“`
Where:
– FCF_t = Free Cash Flow in year t
– r = Discount rate (usually WACC)
– t = Year number
– Terminal Value = FCF_(n+1) / (WACC – g)
Where g = perpetual growth rate
Free Cash Flow Calculation:
“`
FCF = EBIT(1-tax rate) + Depreciation & Amortization – CapEx – ∆Working Capital
“`
Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC):
“`
WACC = (E/V × Re) + (D/V × Rd × (1-T))
“`
Where:
– E = Market value of equity
– D = Market value of debt
– V = E + D
– Re = Cost of equity
– Rd = Cost of debt
– T = Tax rate
Cost of Equity (using CAPM):
“`
Re = Rf + β(Rm – Rf)
“`
Where:
– Rf = Risk-free rate
– β = Beta (systematic risk)
– Rm = Market return
– (Rm – Rf) = Market risk premium
Comparable Company Analysis (CCA)
This method values a company based on how similar companies are valued in the market.
Key Multiples:
Enterprise Value (EV) Multiples:
“`
EV = Market Cap + Total Debt – Cash & Equivalents
EV/EBITDA = Enterprise Value / EBITDA
EV/EBIT = Enterprise Value / EBIT
EV/Sales = Enterprise Value / Revenue
“`
Equity Multiples:
“`
P/E = Stock Price / Earnings Per Share
P/B = Stock Price / Book Value Per Share
P/S = Stock Price / Sales Per Share
“`
Application Process:
Select comparable companies
Calculate multiples for each comparable
Determine appropriate multiple range
Apply multiples to target company metrics
Precedent Transaction Analysis
This method examines recent M&A transactions in the same industry to determine appropriate valuation multiples.
Key Considerations:
Transaction Premium:
“`
Premium = (Offer Price – Pre-announcement Price) / Pre-announcement Price
“`
Control Premium:
“`
Control Premium = (Control Price – Minority Price) / Minority Price
“`
Leveraged Buyout (LBO) Analysis
This model determines the potential return on investment for a leveraged buyout transaction.
Key Metrics:
Internal Rate of Return (IRR):
“`
0 = -Initial Investment + Σ (Cash Flows_t / (1 + IRR)^t) + Exit Value / (1 + IRR)^n
“`
Cash-on-Cash Multiple:
“`
Cash Multiple = Total Cash Received / Total Cash Invested
“`
Debt Considerations:
Debt/EBITDA Ratios
Interest Coverage Ratios:
“`
Interest Coverage = EBIT / Interest Expense
“`
Asset-Based Valuation
Used primarily for asset-heavy businesses or in liquidation scenarios.
Net Asset Value:
“`
NAV = Total Assets – Total Liabilities
“`
Adjusted Net Asset Value:
“`
Adjusted NAV = Market Value of Assets – Market Value of Liabilities
“`
Key Considerations for Valuation
Growth Analysis
– Historical growth rates
– Industry growth prospects
– Competitive position
– Market share trends
Margin Analysis
“`
Gross Margin = (Revenue – COGS) / Revenue
Operating Margin = EBIT / Revenue
Net Margin = Net Income / Revenue
“`
Working Capital Management
“`
Working Capital = Current Assets – Current Liabilities
Working Capital Turnover = Revenue / Average Working Capital
“`
Capital Structure
“`
Debt/Equity Ratio = Total Debt / Total Equity
Debt/EBITDA = Total Debt / EBITDA
“`
Valuation Adjustments
Illiquidity Discount
Typically 20-30% for private companies
Minority Interest Discount
Usually 15-25% for non-controlling stakes
Control Premium
Typically 20-40% above market price
Documentation Requirements
Sources of Information
– Financial statements (3-5 years historical)
– Industry reports
– Management projections
– Market data
– Comparable company information
Key Assumptions
– Growth rates
– Margins
– Capital requirements
– Terminal value assumptions
– Risk factors
Sensitivity Analysis
Create scenarios for:
– Revenue growth
– Margins
– Working capital
– CapEx
– WACC
– Terminal growth rate
Quality Checks
Reasonableness Tests
– Compare implied growth rates to industry averages
– Check implied margins against historical performance
– Validate capital structure assumptions
– Review terminal value as percentage of total value
Cross-Check Methods
– Compare results across different valuation methods
– Analyze and explain variations
– Document key drivers of differences
Risk Factors to Consider
Business Risk
– Industry dynamics
– Competitive position
– Management quality
– Operating leverage
Financial Risk
– Capital structure
– Cash flow stability
– Working capital requirements
– Financial covenant compliance
Market Risk
– Economic conditions
– Interest rates
– Currency exposure
– Regulatory environment
Implementation Guidelines
Data Collection
– Gather historical financials
– Compile industry research
– Collect market data
– Document assumptions
Model Building
– Create detailed financial projections
– Build valuation models
– Document calculations
– Include sensitivity analyses
Review Process
– Check calculations
– Validate assumptions
– Compare to industry benchmarks
– Document key findings
Presentation
– Executive summary
– Detailed analysis
– Supporting schedules
– Risk factors
– Recommendations
Best Practices
Documentation
– Clear explanation of assumptions
– Detailed source notes
– Calculation methodologies
– Risk factors
Model Structure
– Separate inputs and calculations
– Clear formatting
– Error checks
– Version control
Quality Control
– Independent review
– Sensitivity testing
– Cross-checking
– Industry benchmarking
Updates
– Regular review of assumptions
– Market updates
– Industry changes
– Company developments
Based on the comprehensive company valuation guide, there are a few key variables and inputs that are most important to gather when starting a valuation analysis for an early-stage startup:
* Valuation for a startup, the critical variables to collect are:
Revenue projections: Forecast the startup’s expected revenues over the next 3-5 years based on their business model, addressable market size, pricing, customer acquisition expectations, etc. Revenue growth rate assumptions are key.
Expense projections: Project the company’s significant operating expenses, including cost of goods sold, headcount costs, sales & marketing, R&D, and overhead. This helps estimate margins and profitability.
Capital needs: Estimate how much funding the startup will need to raise to hit its projections. Consider costs to build the product, go-to-market spend, working capital needs, etc.
Addressable market: Analyze the startup’s target market size, growth, and unit economics. The company’s ability to capture market share is critical to its potential.
Comparable deals: Research what valuation multiples and terms other startups at a similar stage have raised capital at recently. This provides a benchmark range.
Required return: Determine what IRR hurdle rate investors will expect given the startup’s maturity and risk profile. Seed-stage investors often target a 10x return while growth rounds price closer to 3-5x.
Exit expectations: Outline the likely exit scenarios – IPO, M&A, secondary sale – and the expected valuation multiple ranges in each case. A 10x revenue multiple upon exit is a common target.
Discount rate: The discount rate should reflect the high risk of investing in startups. Rates of 30-50%+ are ordinary for early-stage companies.
Equipped with these key variables, you can take an informed first pass at valuing the startup, likely using the VC method:
Project out annual revenues to the expected exit year
In the exit year, assume a reasonable exit multiple (e.g., 10x revenue)
Discount that exits valuation back to today at the target IRR
Divide the present value by the post-money valuation to see if you earn the IRR
Toggle the valuation to set a price that earns the target return
Of course, startups are tough to value, given their short histories, uncertain futures, and unique risks. The key is making reasonable assumptions, aiming for a valuation range, and constantly updating estimates as the company evolves. Hopefully, this will give you a strong starting point for valuing an early-stage company. Let me know if you have any other questions!
